In MLB The Show 25, only three players hold the coveted 99 overall rating, a distinction that truly sets them apart in the game’s competitive hierarchy. These three titans of mlb stubsbaseball are Shohei Ohtani, Juan Soto, and Aaron Judge—a trio that embodies power, discipline, and sheer elite-level performance across the diamond.
Topping the ratings list is Shohei Ohtani of the Los Angeles Dodgers with a perfect 99 overall. His value in the game is almost supernatural—capable of dominating both as a starting pitcher and as a designated hitter. As one of only three 99-rated players, Ohtani stands unrivaled in flexibility and ability to impact every facet of play. His ratings reflect his real-life dominance, boasting top-tier contact, power, speed, and pitching attributes that make him the most versatile player in the roster.
Joining Ohtani in the exclusive 99 club is Juan Soto of the New York Mets. Soto earns this honor with exceptional attributes in discipline, patience, and power. With 99 ratings in discipline and clutch ability, he consistently performs under pressure. His flawlessness at the plate—working counts, drawing walks, and delivering clutch hits—makes him one of the most reliable offensive weapons in both solo and Diamond Dynasty game modes.
Aaron Judge, the towering New York Yankees slugger, completes the trio of 99 overall superstars. Renowned for his monstrous power against both right- and left-handed pitchers, Judge is a nightmare for opposing pitchers when he makes contact. His raw strength and ability to clear fences with regularity define his presence in the game. As a 99-rated batter, Judge is key to constructing any dominant lineup in MLB The Show 25.
What makes these three players so remarkable is not just their individual excellence, but how they redefine the balance of power in the game. Ohtani offers pitching and hitting, making him a logistical genius for rotation and lineup design. Judge and Soto provide complementary but distinct skillsets—Judge’s home run power contrasts with Soto’s finesse and control. Having any of these players elevates a team’s competitiveness in Franchise mode and MyTeam sessions.
Critically, the rarity of 99 ratings means these players are heavily sought after. Stubs spenders and strategic gamers alike see them as premium investments. Securing one—or ideally all—of these players can shift the balance of power in your lineup. Their status also reflects real-world form: Ohtani continues to transcend expectations, Soto’s move to the Mets boosted his visibility, and Judge solidified himself as baseball’s most feared hitter.
Despite the clear dominance, the game maintains balance through limitations such as rotation depth, salary constraints in Franchise, and high in-game cost in Dynasty. This ensures that even the best players must be paired wisely with supporting cast members. In multiplayer, of course, using any 99-rated player doesn’t guarantee victory—but it surely raises the ceiling of possibility.
Ultimately, Ohtani, Soto, and Judge aren't just the highest-rated players in MLB The Show 25—they are the defining icons of the season. Each embodies a different dimension of greatness: Ohtani’s dual-threat mastery, Soto’s cerebral plate discipline, and Judge’s raw slugging prowess. For anyone looking to build an MVP-caliber squad in any mode of the game, these three are undoubtedly the ultimate targets.
